Click here for a PDF version of this issue of Pipecaster
Hot Water & Heat, the Elephant in the Decarbonization Room; Why Gas is Part of the Solution
By Neil Skidell
The energy required to heat our buildings and produce hot water for domestic use is by far the largest use in the built environment and in particular dense urban environments like New York City. It is the “elephant in the room.”
There is no debate that our buildings need to follow a path to decarbonization; but this must be done in a logical fashion following the general transformation to renewable resources. Three core principles of cost, carbon, and confidence must be followed to achieve beneficial decarbonization. That’s correct—decarbonization must be beneficial to society and that means it must be achieved without upsetting the delicate balance of real estate operating costs and allowable rents.
What is Decarbonization? And how does it differ from Electrification? Why is Fuel Diversity required?
Decarbonization can be defined as acceleratingtransformationtowardsalow-carbonfuture. Anobleeffortatthemacroorpolicylevelbutverychallengingtoimplement at the micro or building level, especially in cold climates. This should not be confused with electrification, decarbonization is the goal, electrification is merely one tool in the box to help us get there.
Electricity by itself is currently an insufficient resource to feed the elephant; it is currently not practical nor possible for a single fuel (Electricity), delivered through a single system (The Grid), using a single technology (Heat Pumps) to always deliver heat and hot water to all buildings and in all weather conditions. Perhaps in the future, or in fantasy land, but not today or even in the next 10 years. The fuel mix and carbon related to electricity production is beyond the scope of this article.
Heating and Hot Water in homes and buildings has long been provided by a variety of fuels (Natural Gas, Oil, Propane and Electricity) and system types selected by an engineer or contractor as the most appropriate for the intended use. This allows building owners and operators the choices required to achieve the desired balance of energy & capital cost, carbon, and confidence.
It is vital to maintain this choice as not all buildings are created equally, they differ in size, materials of construction, year of construction, types of use and occupancy and with that diversity comes heating and hot water needs that vary greatly.
Political Desire Vs. Reality
Politicians say we need to decarbonize building heating and domestic hot water so let’s just switch to electricity and call it a day. Simple to say and easy to understand but inquiring minds say WHAT? In cold climates? In New York State? So what if it takes about 3x the energy input to heat a building vs cool a building. So what if even using the best available heat pump technology it costs at least 2x and as much as 4x as heating with gas. So what if it requires abandoning infrastructure with 2/3 of its useful life left that was installed as best available technology 10 years ago to comply with banning of #6 oil? So what if it involves disrupting the lives of millions of people to allow unnecessary construction in their apartments that will likely decrease their comfort? So what if in the foreseeable future there are no measurable emissions reductions on a systemic basis? So what if we stop providing basic services to tenants so that building owners can fund this expense and pay the increased operating and utility costs? So what if people die because the electric supply becomes unstable and inadequate?
We need to preserve the availability of natural gas as a building fuel in New York State. Energy decisions for critical systems such as heat and hot water must be made considering the three core pillars of cost, carbon, and confidence.
To successfully, economically, and safely decarbonize heat and hot water fuel choice is required. Fuel choice should not be a policy decision and is a fundamental requirement to preserve the safety, security, and comfort of our built environment.
The real story is that of hybridization, different fuels and different systems all working together to achieve the requirements of cost, carbon, and confidence. No one fuel or solution by itself can achieve decarbonization in the near term. Different fuels have different qualities, cost structures and implementation challenges beyond the scope of this article.
Market Forces will play a role.
To have a thriving market that provides fuels for heating and hot water policy must allow for the best technology to be deployed for each use. Often the best economics AND lowest emissions are provided by a combination of technologies and for that to happen policy must allow the continued use of natural gas. Market forces will dictate the rest of the story.
We need to separate the political ideal of Decarbonization from the reality of Decarbonizing buildings in cold climates. People’s lives and economic stature need to be maintained as we, as a society, progress through the transition to clean energy. At the micro level (buildings) it does no good to force economic distress in the form of unneeded capital investment and increased energy costs. To make matters worse, deploying capital and precious operating income to satisfy political folly in the name of improving people’s lives instead of actually improving people’s lives is the worst form of hypocrisy.
Neil J. Skidell is the Managing Director, Green Solutions at The PAR Group. He leads the development and implementation of Carbon reduction strategies for commercial, life sciences, healthcare, and multi-family residential customers through the application of state-of-the-art HVAC and Plumbing technologies. He is an expert in the strategic use of technology to solve energy and water safety, conservation, generation and utilization challenges.
The PAR Group is New York’s preeminent provider of plumbing, heating & air conditioning, fire protection and green solution services. Neil can be contacted at nskidell@pargroup.com.
Winners of the 2023-24 Eugene and Raymond Cardoza Memorial Scholarship
![](https://www.plumbingfoundation.nyc/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Winners-of-the-2023-24-Eugene-and-Raymond-Cardoza-Memorial-Scholarship.jpg)
From L to R: Scholarship Recipients Noah S. Rickman, Nicole M. Radliff, Kamila Utko; UA Plumbers Union Local No. 1 Business Manager Paul O’Connor; ACP President Robert Greenberg; Scholarship Recipient Thomas R. Mansfield; Christina Genovese, Cardoza Plumbing (daughter of Raymond Cardoza, granddaughter of Eugene Cardoza)
The 2024 winners of the Eugene & Raymond Cardoza Memorial Scholarship Program have been determined by a panel of Fordham professors. Further information on the scholarship program can be found on the Association of Contracting Plumbers’ website (acpcny.org). Five recipients will receive $5,000 a year towards a collegiate education. As a reminder, all scholarship applications are reviewed by an independent panel of educators and selections are based upon academic achievement, community service, and extracurricular activities.
The Trustees of the Promotion Fund and the ACP Executive Board are happy to announce the following 2024 winners: Sean Hasretli, Thomas R. Mansfield, Nicole M. Radliff, Noah S. Rickman, Kamila Utko
Congratulations to all the winners, we wish you luck on your future endeavors!
SERVICE NOTICE
NEW REQUIREMENT: Construction Inspection Sign Off Prior to Occupancy Requests in DOB NOW: Inspections
Effective Monday, May 13, 2024, all requests for construction sign off must be submitted in DOB NOW: Inspections. Requests sent by email to ConstructionIR mailboxes will not be processed.
Requests for construction sign off are submitted by selecting Construction Sign Off Prior to Occupancy via the Actions tab for DOB NOW: Build jobs and the Request Inspection selection for BIS jobs. Indicate Office Review in the beginning of the Requester Comments section for DOB NOW jobs or the Additional Information section for BIS jobs before stating any additional wording of the request.
Requests submitted indicating Office Review will be reviewed by the Quality Assurance Team. There are no changes to the existing process for requesting physical construction inspections.
Visit the DOB NOW: Inspections Resources page for the Construction Inspection Sign Off for DOB NOW: Build NB/ALT-CO Jobs and BIS Requesting, Cancelling and Viewing Results guide and additional resources. For assistance, submit an inquiry to the DOB NOW Help Form at nyc.gov/dobnowhelp.
For general questions about the construction sign off request process, email QAconstruction@buildings.nyc.gov or call (212) 323-7253.
Empire State University / Construction Trades License Training Corp. 7-Hour Master Plumber and Master Fire Suppression Contractor License Renewal Course
Please see below the SUNY Empire State University / Construction Trades License Training Corp. 7-Hour Master Plumber and Master Fire Suppression Contractor License Renewal Course Schedule for 2024!
July 24 • August 21 • September 25 • October 23 • November 20 December 19 (Thursday) or January 8, 2025 (TBD)
These courses are all in-house with recorded video. The courses are held at our office at 535 8th Ave, Floor 17, New York, NY 10018. We are not holding virtual courses.
You can access registration information here: nyconstructiontrades.org
2024 NYS Legislative Session Wrap-Up
The NYS Legislature had its last “scheduled” session day on Thursday, June 6 but extended session through the early morning of Saturday, June 8. It was similar to 2023 in that it was not the most productive year, with another late budget (passed over the weekend of April 20th) leaving little time for other legislative priorities to move through committees between May and June.
Congestion Pricing
As has been the buzz throughout June, Governor Kathy Hochul announced a pause to the implementation of the congestion pricing program (which was set to start June 30, 2024) citing unforeseen consequences and the impact of COVID on small businesses that are still struggling. The Plumbing Foundation commends the Governor for this action, as it truly will have a negative impact on businesses and residents of the so-called “central business district.” However, this created a last minute frenzy in the state legislature with several ideas proposed to close the gap for the MTA on the expected funding from the tolling program. At one point, Governor Hochul proposed an increase on NYC businesses, but which was not adopted by the Legislature. MTA CEO Janno Lieber has indicated that the MTA may have to increase fares and cut services, halt certain projects, and consider layoffs. As of the date of this printing, NYC Comptroller Brad Lander held a press conference where he and other stakeholders said they are developing a legal strategy to challenge the Governor’s decision.
NY HEAT Act
As a reminder, Governor Hochul proposed the Affordable Gas Transition Act (AGTA) in her executive budget, a similar proposal to the NY Home Energy Affordable Transition Act (NY HEAT Act) whereby the 100-foot rule, a subsidy for new gas hookups, would be eliminated. Fortunately, this was not adopted in the budget but was heavily pushed by the Senate in the final weeks of session; the Senate already passed the NY HEAT Act in March of this year, but sponsors and advocates urged the Assembly to pass. Fortunately, the bill was not a priority for the Assembly, and did not pass.
Modular Construction
As for the Plumbing Foundation’s modular construction legislation requiring all modular construction projects in NYC to comply with licensing requirements, which was passed by both houses in 2022 and vetoed by Governor Hochul, due to several factors including the delayed budget adoption, it did not pass this year. It made it to the Senate Finance Committee but was held amidst talks with the City. The Plumbing Foundation continues to prioritize this legislation as modular construction becomes more prevalent.
Other
The major legislation that did pass both houses at the end of session included: SAFE for Kids Act (requiring parental consent for social media use) and the Child Data Protection Act (prohibiting websites from collecting and using minors’ information without informed consent); Climate Change Superfund Act (creating a climate change adaptation cost recovery program targeting big oil companies, similar to Vermont’s recent law); NYC red light cameras (authorizing an expansion of red light cameras); absentee ballot drop boxes (authorizing local boards of elections to set up absentee ballot drop boxes); and speeding up downstate casino licenses (requiring the Gaming Commission to choose by March 2026). All bills are subject to approval/veto by Governor Hochul.
Some of the relevant legislation that failed to pass both houses included: the NY Heat Act (mentioned above); Packaging Reduction and Recycling Infrastructure Act (reducing single use plastics); and the Bucks for Boilers Act (creating new fund to push electrification and prohibiting in-kind replacement of fossil fuel equipment).
As always is the case, the state legislature never formally “gavels out” in the event of a need for a special session later in the year. While this is extremely rare, the Plumbing Foundation will notify the industry in such a case.
NYC.ID Now required for DOB NOW Filings
THE PLUMBING FOUNDATION’S ENVIRONMENTAL STATEMENT
Since its establishment in 1986, the Plumbing Foundation has worked diligently to ensure the plumbing industry has as little a “carbon footprint” on New York City as possible. The plumbing industry has historically utilized environmentally friendly materials such as recycled cast-iron and copper piping/fittings. The Foundation will continue in its role of protecting New York City as well as being an advocate for the environment by strengthening its water/sanitary regulations and thereby reducing wasteful water consumption in the City.
WaterSense® Partners Save
THE PIPECASTER is published by the Plumbing Foundation City of New York, Inc.
Lawrence J. Levine, Chairman; Louis J. Buttermark, Vice Chairman; Barr Rickman, Treasurer; April McIver, Executive Director; Terence O’Brien, Editor. Board of Directors: Anthony D. Altimari, Paul Belli, Marc Breslaw, Louis J. Buttermark, Harris Clark, Alex Greenberg, Nicholas Katragis, Angelo Lemodetis, Lawrence J. Levine, Scott Lyons, Barr Rickman, Richard Turchiano